Thursday, November 19, 2026

Some Thoughts On SLEEPY HOLLOW (1999)

Released on this day--19 November--in 1999, Tim Burton's SLEEPY HOLLOW. One of the director's absolute best films to date and, visually, his most accomplished, this adaptation of Washington Irving's classic tale was transformed by its creators into a magnificent homage to Hammer horror, Roger Corman's Edgar Allan Poe cycle, Disney's adaptation of the same story and, most especially, the films of Mario Bava.



It's always odd to me that in discussions of the movie, the Bava influence, which pervades the movie and Burton has certainly been open in his admiration for the Italian director's work, is barely, if ever, even mentioned. When genre nerds tap out any brief breakdown of the film's DNA, Hammer--from which the film arguably takes less than from any of its major influences--is the one most prominently mentioned. In a way this is understandable--the presence of Hammer vets Christopher Lee and Michael Gough for supporting parts tips the hat 'til it's on the nose.

Christopher Lee, looking like the Angel of Death pronouncing sentence


Bava's presence is directly felt in that way at times as well. Stunning Lisa Marie's holey face...


...directly echoes stunning Barbara Steele's from Bava's BLACK SUNDAY (1960)...


But perhaps the biggest borrow from Bava--which I've never seen acknowledged anywhere--is the plot. Writers Kevin Yagher and Andrew Kevin Walker essentially take the Irving tale and filter it through the plot of Bava's KILL, BABY, KILL (1966). The investigator arriving in a foreboding backwater to look into mysterious murder by way of newfangled scientific techniques, finding the place under apparent siege by an evil spirit, the good witch who, it turns out, is trying to protect people, the secret behind the ghost's murder spree--so much of the Bava picture was reproduced that SLEEPY HOLLOW would almost qualify as a remake (though that would be a great disservice to Burton and co.).

Some of Corman's Poe is worn by SLEEPY HOLLOW on its sleeve as well, and here, the big influence is THE PIT & THE PENDULUM (1962), from which it draws, among other things, dream sequences/flashbacks that reveal and explore the protagonist's psychology. In one, a young Ichabod is lured to a torture-chamber by a woman ghostily calling of his name, echoing PIT--"Nicholaaaas" becomes "Ichaboood" and is made to sound almost identical. And we get this sticks-in-the-brain image:


...which is pulled from another sticks-in-the-brain image--Barbara Steele from THE PIT & THE PENDULUM:



The mechanics of the Headless Horseman chase setpiece from the animated Disney adaptation of Irving, half of THE ADVENTURES OF ICHABOD AND MR. TOAD, are also reproduced by Burton in two parts of his film. Irving's Ichabod Crane was a cowardly, superstitious wuss, which Disney took to a, um, cartoonish extreme. Burton and Depp go in a somewhat different direction, keeping the cowardly wuss part and taking it to that same extreme--so extreme that it stops being an amusing character quirk and just becomes annoying then appalling. When grown-ass Ichabod enters a spooky cottage in a spooky forest with a pistol in his hand while taking cover behind a young boy, that gag has gone way too far. This is made worse by the fact that this Ichabod is, contra Irvinr and Disney, an Enlightenment-era anti-superstitious rationalist, someone who shouldn't be this skittish in the face of the unknown. He argues for the use of "the latest scientific techniques" in investigative work but is perpetually near to fainting at the sight of blood. Or bugs. Or just about anything.

There are some plot problems with SLEEPY HOLLOW as well (and here, I'm going to get into some spoilers, so if you haven't seen the movie, do yourself a favor: stop reading and watch it before finishing this).

The film is set in 1799, and it establishes that the Hessian mercenary who became the Headless Horseman was killed 20 years earlier during the American Revolutionary War. In a flashback, we see that the Hessian was being pursued through a forest in Winter by Patriot forces and was killed--beheaded--when 2 creepy little girls he randomly encounters give away his position. Back to 1799: epic Miranda Richardson, who is revealed to be the real villain of the story, is later revealed to have been one of those girls. That's how she knew where the Hessian was killed and where he was buried. But Richardson was 41 when she made this and, with her hair greyed, her characters is clearly meant to be even older. But he character could only be 24.




Near the end, when Ichabod uncovers some crucial information, he high-tails it to a creepy windmill on a hill. This is, indeed, where Richardson's character has taken luscious Christina Ricci's character but there's no way Depp's Ichabod could know that. He just shows up there and coincidentally just in the nick of time, having been given absolutely no reason to go there or be there.

Those kind of complaints aside--and the bigger complaint that they would have been comically easy to fix--SLEEPY HOLLOW is an exceptionally good movie. There's nary a sour note struck by Depp, Ricci, Richardson or any of the complimentarily killer cast--Christopher Walken makes for a particularly ghoulish Hessian apparition and Richardson understood her assignment very well--and Burton and co. conjure up a dark world before our eyes full of some of the most memorable imagery of the director's entire filmography, sure to warm (or perhaps chill) the hearts of veteran horror fans in attendance at a showing and send faint-hearted lasses not of the clan but along for the ride fleeing to the arms and laps of their dates.























--j.